• 3 Posts
  • 382 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: June 19th, 2023

help-circle






  • If you can’t even count, I don’t see a reason to listen to anything else you have to say on intelligent. There are two graphs in the paper you cited, the one that I’ve posted in another comment (figure 1) and a pie chart of prostitution regimes in appendix C. The former shows some places have the substitution effect overshadow the scale effect and it some places the opposite occurs. The latter is a pie chart that doesn’t have a dependent variable.






  • They already said it’s derogatory. It’s like if somebody called you on idiot. The denotation would be that your intelligence is lacking. The connotation would be that you’re a lesser person for it and cause issues for those around you. In the same way, whore and prostitute have to some denotation but different connotations with the former having the negative connotation. Is that simple enough for you to understand now?




  • I already mentioned the problems with your source is another comment, but now I’m going to address the “science”.

    First up, science doesn’t run on certainty. If you had actually read the paper, you might have noticed this sentence:

    Therefore, the true number of human trafficking victims is unknown (Belser, de Cock & Mehran, 2005).

    Science also does not take place in a vacuum; it is political. The statistics gathered rely on political entities that have agendas. The statistics are imperfect. They even mention this:

    The main limitation of the UNODC data however is that reporting will arguably depend on the quality of institutions, judicial and police effectiveness, in particular, but also on how aware the international community is about trafficking problems in a particular country.

    Until you learn to read things not to prove a point, but to understand them, get science’s name out of your mouth.


  • Ffs, read more than the abstract.

    On average, countries where prostitution is legal experience larger reported human trafficking inflows.

    That “on average” is doing a lot of heavy lifting. I know it’s really hard to read all the way to the end, but that’s where the pictures are. The regression chosen is linear, but the relationship looks to be anything but. Some countries have to substitution effect overshadow the scale effect, some see the opposite. Reducing it to legalized prostitution increases trafficking is facile at best.

    graph from cited source showing trafficking vs prostitution